I don’t care if you are for or against the proposed health care bill. I just ask that you make your decisions based on fact.
I read an article today that points out the fallacies in a chain e-mail that opponents of the health bill have been passing around.
For the purpose of full disclosure, I support this healthcare legislation. If you do not, that is your prerogative. I would prefer that you don’t insult me personally for seeing things differently than you do. Maybe I’m growing more liberal than libertarian these days.
But again, don’t base how you “see” things on lies.
Among the myths busted in this article are free healthcare for illegal aliens, rationing, the “death panel” (though not referred to as the “death panel” in this article), and the idea that the “public option” will put private insurers out of business.
Re. illegal aliens:
“Jennifer Tolbert, an independent health care analyst at the Kaiser Family Foundation, a nonpartisan foundation that studies health care reform … [says] the claim that the bill provides free health care for illegal immigrants is particularly egregious … ‘No one’s provided with free health care. That’s ridiculous.’”
Re. the public option outcompeting private insurers:
Page 124: “specifically states that health care providers do not have to accept patients under the public option” and page 127: “Again, there may be a broader case to be made that the government can outcompete private insurers through the public option, but this section of the plan only applies to payments to doctors for patients who are part of the public option. The government does not set wages for doctors because doctors are free to decline to see the patients.“
I think the public option would only put private insurance out of business if *all doctors* had to opt in. But they don’t. I believe you’ll still likely get better healthcare through private insurance — as long as they can’t drop you, and will pay out.
This isn’t as in-depth as I’d like to get, b/c I’m only sneaking a few minutes at work while our system is down.
But it just drives me NUTS to hear people like my father-in-law repeating everything he hears on O’Reilly and Hannity. “The media tries to tell you how to think,” he says, of the ‘liberal’ media. OK, so Fox doesn’t???
I love the man, don’t get me wrong. But for all the conservative complaining about paying taxes for public benefits, I’d just like to see what they’d do if the gov’t tried to take AWAY their Social Security and their Medicare — two “socialist” programs.
Another good article I’ve read on healthcare is here. The author outlines how one reason it’s so expensive is b/c it’s so much BETTER than it used to be. He also points out how smokers and the obese actually end up costing us LESS in the long run b/c they die sooner.
Last month I finally paid off a $1,000+ emergency room bill that I received *three years ago,* when I had health insurance, but it was such crap insurance that it didn’t pay out anything. It’s no laughing matter when you have no insurance and have to go bankrupt (I didn’t, but I didn’t go for anything really serious).
If you have ever suffered any sort of financial hardship due to your lack of health insurance, I don’t see how you could *not* support healthcare reform. The fact is, we need universal healthcare, healthcare that you don’t lose because you lose a job or get sick. Whether this universal healthcare is handled by government, or can somehow be supported by the free market — well, that’s up to *us* to decide, based on FACTS about what works here and what works in other countries … and what DOESN’T work here and in other countries.
APPENDIX
I first posted this as a FB note and immediately drew the ire of some folks to my right. I think I made some more pretty good points, so here they are:
I do agree we need tort reform. Malpractice insurance raises doctors’ costs, which are passed on to patients.
I also think we should ban direct pharmaceutical advertising, starting with TV. Is that anti 1st amendment? I don’t know, but I hate those stupid ads. They cost tons of money that could go into *supplying* people with drugs – that their doctors inform them about – not the TV.
I don’t think the gov’t would necessarily do a stupendous job running healthcare. I don’t WANT the gov’t to completely take it over. I still think we should have co-pays (sliding scale). The best insurance I ever had was an HMO, Kaiser Permanente. I just believe we need a health *safety net* for all, whether it’s provided by private or public entities, the fed gov’t, or state & county gov’ts. Sometimes people can’t help it if they get in a horrible car wreck or give birth to a child with severe birth defects, and they can’t afford the bills, just as example.
Second comment:
Since we live in a country where people make varying levels of income – janitors make little, doctors make less – which I *agree* with b/c it takes more training, skills and smarts to be a doctor – the current system also provides varying levels of health care, based on what ppl can afford.
Everyone can’t be a doctor. Someone has to be a janitor. A janitor shouldn’t make what a doctor does. But if said janitor, with little/no insurance, gets in a horrible wreck or suffers a similar unforeseen health disaster, he likely would *get* the emergency health care he needs, thanks to the Hippocratic Oath, but he would also get stuck with thousands in medical bills, and if he can’t pay (how could he?) he may have to file bankruptcy, lose his home, ruin his credit, etc, thus keeping him mired in poverty.
I just think we need a safety net. Which we don’t have now.
Third comment:
Yeah, tell you the truth, I don’t know where the money will come from either. We can’t afford what we have already, be that Social Security or Afghanistan. Not that I’m against those things; just that we already have such staggering debt.
I will be first to admit I don’t have all the answers. I just hope my husband keeps his job; if he lost it we’d be up the creek b/c I’m an independent contractor and don’t get benefits through *my* job. BUT here’s a more libertarian thought – if businesses are *forced* to provide health care to employees, there will be fewer employees, and probably more independent contractors like myself.



And last but not least, Nick Simmons …